Monday, June 10, 2024

Children's Media That Develops Skills for Understanding Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion- Focus on Books!

Here it is. 2024. I come back to this blog after four years, having experienced struggles and opportunities to problem solve, adapt and transform throughout the pandemic and beyond- as all of us did in our own way. I became a virtual music teacher, extending that role all the way to 2023, before moving to a different state, making awesome new additions to my family (and anticipating still more), and teaching in person again.

Teaching in person this year quite literally reawakened muscles needed for interacting with young children. At the end of the day, I was so tired- my body and mind ached in ways that reminded me of the scope, depth and importance of this work. In reflection of my own work and in observation of the education community as a whole, I asked myself questions about the goals of post pandemic arts education- particularly around teaching prosocial skills.

The biggest uncertainty for me was how to enhance those crucial skills of empathy in students- so needed to foster kindness and respect. Working with students in a more intentional way on diversity, equity, and inclusion is long past due and so needed as well, but with the added need to explore empathy, kindness, and respect, it adds a prerequisite to this intention. In addition, this work is not complete, especially around equity, if we as educators do not address racism- what it is and how to be an antiracist. For me, the intention for this work goes particularly toward children ages 6-8, who experienced the pandemic in their early childhood years.

Exploring these issues through the arts gives children the opportunity to learn about these important concepts in a representational way that increases understanding, and encourages behavior that is sensitive to these topics in lived experiences. This combination of theory and practice is what drives authentic learning around any topic, but perhaps most importantly here.

We know early childhood is the time when the brain develops the most, and children can learn prosocial behaviors that can quite literally make the world a better place. Children ages 6-8 are still learning and practicing these skills. It's never too late to practice, really, but I feel giving some extra love and attention to this age group would help fill a need to reinforce skills that started to develop during early childhood- for them perhaps disrupted because of the pandemic.

While my previous work on this blog has focused on children ages 0-6, I'll be extending my work to those a bit older to encourage awareness and intention around these topics. In particular, I want to connect families with media that helps build an understanding of diversity, equity, inclusion, and antiracism, along with empathy, kindness, and respect. The list I'll provide today is in no way comprehensive, but I hope to add more to it- so stay tuned! Today's focus will be books. I'll also offer ideas for how to put these skills to practice, inspired by the lessons the books offer.


Diversity - Whoever You Are by Mem Fox - I chose this book because the art reflects diverse faces. It reflects and celebrates global diversity, differences in where we live and the languages we speak. It also shares how we are the same in poignant, relatable ways.


Equity - A Little Book About Equity by Courn "Courtney" Ahn - This book does a great job explaining that we don't always have what we need, and that what we need can be different. When everyone gets what they need, that's equity!


Inclusion - All Are Welcome by Alexandra Penfold - A beautiful reflection of how all schools should welcome diversity, this book shows how schools can be inclusive, safe spaces.


Antiracism - Antiracist Baby by Ibram X. Kendi - This is a great book for children and adults to learn the ways we can disrupt the systematic racism around us- this is also an awesome new find for me.


Empathy - The Last Stop on Market Street by Matt de la Peña- I was delighted to find out about this book. It made me remember the time I spent living on Market Street in San Francisco, and how my empathy grew for the different people I encountered in the city.


Kindness - Counting on Community by Innosanto Nagara - In a format that resonates with my artistic inclinations, this numbers book shows how we can show kindness and care in a community. We can "count" on each other- showing kindness towards each other as well as for the community and environment as a whole.


Respect - Noisy Night by Mac Barnett - I like this book because it highlights a simple way to show respect, to be quiet so others can sleep, in a funny way but also showing that our behavior and actions can affect those around us.


Diversity - Just Ask! Be Different, Be Brave, Be You by Sonia Sotomayor - The individual experiences shared here increase awareness of both visible and invisible diversity. Shared, human struggles can increase empathy- a unique testimony to the lived experience of diverse individuals!


Equity - Malala's Magic Pencil by Malala Yousafzai - Malala's story is one every child should know. With her magic pencil, Malala at first wishes she could magically draw into existence whatever people might need, wishing equity for her community but unable to make those wishes a reality. She later learns that writing and speaking up to challenge inequity is the brave and powerful act that can bring help to those in need.


Inclusion - Change Sings: A Children's Anthem by Amanda Gorman - Gorman's anthem for how children can bring change to communities is a true collaboration with illustrator Loren Long. We see a young girl with a guitar including others in her efforts to help her community. In one of the illustrations, this effort is met with resistance- a boy covers his ears when she shares her message through music. In the next illustration, we see the boy helping to make a wheelchair ramp, so we are left to question how the girl was able to include and accommodate the boy. The text reads, "I show others tolerance, Though it may take some courage. I don't make a taller fence, But fight to build a better bridge." Students enjoy finding the narrative in the illustrations- it increases understanding of the text!


Antiracism - Freedom River by Doreen Rappaport- I have struggled to share the harsh realities of racism and slavery with younger students. This book is a great starting point because it depicts the associated hate and violence in an honest but age appropriate way. This understanding of history is so necessary to be able to grasp the extension of systematic racism in our communities today- and how to disrupt it as an antiracist.


Empathy - The Invisible Boy by Trudy Ludwig - I feel it's necessary to teach children that empathy can be turned "on" and "off" in our brains. We do it unconsciously, and it is called dehumanization. This book gives insight into what it's like to be treated that way, and to make us more conscious of how we can "see" people - their feelings, their strengths, their humanity.


Kindness - We're All Wonders by R.J. Palacio AND The Year We Learned to Fly by Jacqueline Woodson -I'm including both of these books here because in both books, the characters face unkindness, and retreat to an imaginary place of complete acceptance and freedom to be who they are, rather than be unkind or negative in return. This similarity was intriguing to me. While The Year We Learned to Fly raises awareness about the folk allegory that depicts mental freedom from slavery, both books highlight a protective mental strategy we all possess. It also shows us if kindness can exist in our imagination, it can exist in reality as well.


Respect - The Giving Tree by Shel Silverstein - This classic book is sometimes lauded as an allegory for the need to show gratitude, which is part of a practice of respect, but I see it as going further. Disrespect occurs when our focus is only on our own needs/wants, not those of others. The tree's demise shows what happens when disrespect goes unchecked. This book can start a discussion about thinking about and respecting what others need: boundaries, the ability to flourish, contentment, and yes, to be shown gratitude.


Diversity - Attend community events that celebrate diversity. MLK Day, Lunar New Year, Juneteenth, and Pride events are a few examples. Take advantage of the family friendly activities these events have to offer!


Equity - Involve young ones in donating to food, clothes, and other reusable items. Spend time shopping at stores that sell recycled items as well- this shows that we don't need to buy new items all the time, especially when those items are not affordable to others. In addition, support sharing during play.


Inclusion - At the playground or during other family activities in the community, model for your children how to include others in play. Think of ways to include children who may need support or accommodations to participate. Seek out spaces that are genuinely inclusive to all families- or provide your own!


Antiracism - Seek out spaces to play or visit that allow opportunities for your children to interact with others who do not look like them. Support your children in avoiding using and calling out micro-aggressions, using a growth mindset and awareness of your knowledge deficits and biases. Do this work with the intention of giving your children skills to be antiracists- it will! You may also make some friends along the way and do some disrupting of your own!


Empathy - Model empathy during play by caring for those who are hurt and helping to work out problems that arise. Additionally, just like in The Last Stop on Market Street, field questions children ask about people they encounter in the community by having them try to imagine and appreciate peoples’ feelings and life experiences.


Kindness - During those moments your children are not happy with someone or something, practice focusing on the good or positive- even if that takes some imagination! Help children find the kind words to say and actions to take. Model kindness to others by lifting others up when they seem down.


Respect - During play, support your child in respecting what others need- personal space, kind words, words of gratitude. Be persistent- think of this work as a process that can be fully realized over your child's entire development- that's until they are 25! Be consistent- model and ask for respect as a daily expectation.

Wednesday, July 8, 2020

Social Learning During Social Distancing

It has been a while- over a year- since I posted to this blog! I have no excuse except that I have been fairly busy and stressed (just like everyone else right now). I am writing just about a week after the last day of my school year- a year that of course had a surprising and challenging shift to distance learning.

As an educator, if I have learned anything this year, it's that creative problem solving can help you wade through unforeseen circumstances. However, it takes a full on effort- a constant attention to everyone involved. You have to care- a lot- and make adjustments based on feedback.

As a parent, life has not been dissimilar. I know the stress and social isolation we've been experiencing isn't particularly healthy for us, but it could be a learning opportunity. This has been a tough problem to "creative" our way around- but not impossible. Plus, getting creative about social learning opportunities for our children right now is a good way to model flexibility and resilience!

Here are some options you may have considered to offer social learning opportunities for your little ones during social distancing:

  • You and other immediate family members- your child's first teachers
  • Interactive virtual (FaceTime, Zoom, etc)- can give your child a sense of cause and effect, develop social language, and can model participation in a community
  • Non-interactive (children's media- TV, movies, books, music, etc)- allow your child to see/hear and learn about different social scenarios and develop empathy 
  • In person (socially distancing with people outside on walks, or with extended family if you make that decision)- still available- just please stay safe (wear a mask, socially distance)

With safety first and foremost, opportunities for social learning will look different now, but they are still as abundantly available! Let's take a closer look at how you can offer safe social learning opportunities for your little ones during social distancing. Here are my recommendations:

Take an Online Class There are a variety of offerings for families with young children out there- the beauty of which is you don't have to live close to the teacher, and there is flexibility around the timing. For example, check out these online offerings from children's musicians.

Stay Connected With Playgroups Online This is a way especially for parents of babies/toddlers to stay connected (and sane)! Highly recommended. If you weren't in a playgroup already, try forming one online.

Listen to the Radio This time honored media source connects us to our community because it's  interactive. Try contacting the DJ to make a request! Here are some recommendations (in alphabetical order):
Learn More About Social Justice I recommend the Zinn Education Project. It has resources appropriate for Pre-K to adult. My son (11 years old) and I are using it right now to understand the history and continued effects of systematic racism in our country. Alphabet Rockers, Teaching Tolerance, and The Mosaic Project are all also resources I have used as an educator and as a parent.


Learn About Spirituality and Meditation With many places of worship offering virtual services, now is a good time to learn about different religions without the stigma of perhaps being an outsider to that community- or being that family with the kids who are maybe not that quiet. The more positive messages about universal love and helping those in need, and even the more controversial topics, are great talking points that may tie in to what you learn about social justice. Virtual services also usually offer positivity and peaceful meditation opportunities you can model for your little one- worth a try! (Or you could try the "Calm" app- I'm on the fence about this app. Will probably write a separate article about it).

Donate to Community Helpers As strange as it may sound to recommend watching a late night television host for ideas to donate to community helpers right now, I recommend watching Jimmy Fallon. As a parent of two little girls, he knows what's up, and his YouTubes usually have links to donate. So you feel a little bit more sane by laughing a bit, and then you get to feel like you are helping your community- a win win. How does this help your little ones, you ask? They get to see you in a better mood, and you can explain how you helped the community- you will be a model of resilience and empathy- go you!

Take Walks This is a way to stay connected to one's community that doesn't require a computer, doesn't cost a thing, and is a health boost in so many ways! I recommend saying hello to strangers, sharing or going off the path to maintain social distance, and going at around twilight- it's cooler, and where we live, we can walk with the fireflies!



Bond with a Pet Now is a great time to add a pet to your family, or pay extra attention to your pet(s). Pets can give that much needed unconditional love, develop empathy in your little ones, and can be genuine friends/companions! Have your little one help you feed, walk, or play with your pet- they will love it!

Mail a Letter/Gift! This is a great way to remind those family and friends you are close with that you are there for them. My son has really enjoyed getting letters and gifts in the mail- and it's an opportunity to show gratitude/reciprocate.

Be Real/ Feel Your Feelings As someone who experienced a crisis situation during their child's early childhood years, I was coached to be real and not to hide my feelings from my little one. Our instinct may be to shelter our little ones from any feelings that aren't happy. It's actually a better idea to process the whole range of emotions whether or not you have space apart from your child. It's not easy, and it isn't always pretty, but weathering those storms is a good opportunity to model how to process those feelings and still be okay- to be resilient and forgive ourselves and others. The operative word here is that these emotional storms are temporary- never lasting/harmful to our little ones- but learning opportunities. For example it may be okay to cry in front of your little one, self-calm, and make amends, but never okay to to direct inappropriate physical anger their way. For more information on how to prevent/report domestic violence, check out the National Domestic Violence Hotline.

FaceTime or Socially Distance In Person With Close Family and Friends In addition to connecting through FaceTime, my family has chosen to meet in person for special occasions. We wear masks inside and are considerate of each other's space and health needs. (Please keep in mind the health needs of your family when making this decision).



To anyone who comes across this blog- I hope this was helpful! Feedback is welcome: margotbevington@gmail.com. Or comment below.








Saturday, March 2, 2019

Screen Time for Young Children - A Happy Medium

This final article, on finding a happy medium for our children's use of screens - for learning, for enjoyment, and for their safe use - finds me in a bit of a dilemma. Can a happy medium actually be found? I think there can be, but I say so with caution.

Those of you following these articles were kind enough to participate in the poll I posted here. The question was: "Without looking it up, I know the Pediatrician recommended amounts of screen time for young children throughout their development." The two answer choices were "agree" or "disagree." The results were- 17% agreed and 83% disagreed. I think it's safe to say that those results mean we maybe should maybe pay a bit more attention to those numbers: 0 hours per day for babies under 2, with monitored, limited introduction around 18 months, 1 hour per day for children ages 2-5, and 2 hours per day for children older than 5, even into their teens.

There are plenty of great screen time opportunities to be found for children in using learning apps, watching shows/movies for education or entertainment, and even playing video games, but as current events have shown us, it's a good idea to be vigilant and at least partially monitor use for children of all ages. So I think that happy medium lies somewhere in between monitoring the amount, type, and the user experience of screens for our children.

I leave you with two videos I found about screen time for young children. One reflects research done in the US and one reflects more recent research done in the UK. The videos may leave you with more questions, as they did me, but please take a moment to watch, and leave questions and comments below. Maybe there is a chance to find some clarity and that happy medium here- for parents, educators, and for children. Thanks for spending some time with me to reflect on screen time for our kids!

Links to videos:
Is Screen Time Bad for Your Kids?
Mayo Clinic Minute: How Much Screen Time is Too Much for Kids?

Screen Time for Young Children- How to Monitor?

So, let's be reasonable here. Children love technology, especially video games and watching their favorite shows and movies- my child foremost among them. It could be argued that early childhood is a good time to let children explore the basics of operating current devices, so they become technology "fluent" - ready to draw on that fluency later on when they become the next great software engineers.

I let my son watch YouTube and use apps on my IPhone, monitored, ever since he was 2. Monitored because 1) I didn't easily have money to replace my IPhone if he drops it, 2) I wanted to choose what he had access to in terms of content, and 3) I enjoyed the time spent with him using the device. We didn't have a TV, so I would watch YouTube with him. Quite honestly, out of all the media we found, there was only one video that turned out to be very much different than what we expected. It was a Calliou video in which some choice words had been altered. (Be careful when watching the Calliou apple picking episode online)!

My son has wanted his own IPad ever since he was 3. We didn't have one at home, but one was used at his preschool. At age 10, he doesn't have one yet because I have found both the cost and the potential inappropriate online content inhibitive. However, I got him a LeapPad when he was 7. The learning games and curated online content seemed more age appropriate. I got him a DS when he was 9, and then a Switch when he was 10 (because his DS was stolen from my school classroom when he left it there overnight - insert unhappy parent/teacher face emoji here).

Why has my son wanted his own device since he was old enough to request it? Probably because we had fun using a device together, and because we model device use as adults, me foremost among them. I am constantly working on a computer or my smartphone at home- the effect of having both a "day" job as a teacher (meaning this job extends well beyond working hours) and managing a small business as an independent artist and publisher.

Since I'm on screens myself a lot at home, and my now 10 year old son has access to his Switch, he's allowed to use it, partially unmonitored, for a set amount of time. On the one hand, I can see how much time he has been using his Switch with a handy Parental Control app, as well as disable some online features that could be inappropriate at this point. On the other hand, I'm not there with him when he uses it. I've been more vigilant, however, since hearing about recent hacking of children's media this week. If you don't know what I'm talking about, check your messages from your child's school. My county's public school system issued this warning: "Content that may start out as a normal video, game or message can quickly display threats, violence and offensive language and images."

The message also included this suggestion: "Closely monitor your child's online activities." For a 10 year old, that might mean explaining what this problem is so he is aware. In addition, one of my projects this weekend is to really get a better idea what his user experience is like. For instance, he wants to do more on one of his games, and is telling me he needs a Nintendo account, so we're going to figure out what that entails. If he was younger, knowing what I know now, it would mean taking a break from all new online content until I know for sure it's safe. Even though I was the one searching out and watching videos with my son, it did not prevent us stumbling upon an inappropriate video. Googling what I wanted, and using the first video on the search result list led to our Calliou mishap.

As parents, we can be vigilant at home, but what about at school? Leaders of learning have met with this problem since the introduction of internet to schools. Students, hidden behind their screens, access inappropriate content - even though they are supposed to be doing something else - despite the school's rules or firewall. Although some efforts have been made (see links below), I think much more could be done for schools to help protect students and alert teachers and administrators of inappropriate screen use.

Technology has advanced so quickly, it seems like we have often had difficulty foreseeing its potential harmful effects and misuse, from recent hacking to children's media to using it polarize people and sow discord. I believe these challenges are surmountable, however. Technology can also bring people together, make us smarter (we can learn from our mistakes), and help spread positive messages in the world. Take that- people out there who are trying to mess with our kids!!!

Next Generation Firewalls Do More Than Block Traffic
Best Firewalls 2019
Protect Children From Harmful Material and People on the Internet

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

Screen Time for Young Children- the Outs

So...now for the "outs" of screen time for young children. As you may have guessed there are plenty of reasons to limit the amount of screen time for young children- and studies to back them up. Click here to see the pediatrician recommended amount of screen time for each developmental age and here for a current study about the effects of screen time on the brain, but before you do, take part in my poll, to your right.

Doctors taut a "subtle damage" that occurs with excessive screen use. Recent studies show children spending an average of 7 hours a day in front of screens. That is over 3 times what is recommended, and concerning given what risk there is for the developing brain's frontal lobe. In fact, researchers have found that excessive screen time can atrophy (lessen) parts of the the frontal lobe important for executive function and empathy. That's a big deal- children need to be able to make positive choices to get through their day and accomplish tasks (executive function) and one would hope children would become adults with hopefully enough empathy to make the world a better place.

While some screen use is arguably "better" than others (using a computer to do school work vs. watching screen violence for example),  the dopamine associated with pleasurable screen use can also be somewhat addictive. If you have experienced a child who is unreasonably beyond unhappy at being asked to turn off a screen, you might be witnessing this effect. If you can liken their behavior to yours after not being able to have your morning coffee- maybe it's time to limit screens a bit?

Game-like learning apps take advantage of this effect. When children experience a dopamine rush while learning math in a game-like app like Dreambox, will they be addicted to learning math? It's an interesting question, and I think for some young students, the answer might be yes. However, how much should game-like learning apps drive the learning of students today?

Especially for younger students, I would mostly recommend social, play based learning over game-like learning apps. As a leader of learning, for students in Pre-K to 2nd grade, I would be a little apprehensive to see groups of children this age asked to sit in front of a screen for more than 30 minutes at a time. For 3rd grade and up, I see no problem including screen time for game-like learning apps as long as it's within pediatrician recommended guidelines, and keeps in mind children are probably spending additional time on screens at home.

In conclusion for the "outs" of screen time for young children, while I highly recommend- to educators and families- following the pediatrician recommended amount of screen time for young children, I realize educators and parents must make their own choices. To that effect, I'll share that I'm very honest with my son about screen time. I've let him know what studies show it does to your brain, and I'd like him to follow what doctors recommend for him. He doesn't like it when I limit his screen time, but my hope is that he'll be able to forgive me for it later.


Saturday, February 23, 2019

Screen Time for Young Children- the Ins

Now for the first installment on that series of articles I mentioned about screen time for young children. Today I will focus on how using screen based learning opportunities can help young children- the "ins" of screen time for young children. BTW- if you have a moment, please respond to the screen time poll to your right.

Knowing what the "ins" are for screen time and young children (ages 0-8) is tricky. Besides TV, computer/video games didn't enter my home until I was 10, the age my son is now. (Dark Castle on the MacPlus, anyone)?  I know that I enjoyed playing video games and reaching the elusive "end" of the game. My brother and I would have "friendly" competition to see who could beat the game first, (Super Mario- 1-3). We share simpatico to this day involving the goal setting and surmountable challenges posed by early video games. My brother and I both have wicked hand eye coordination and ability to problem solve with trial and error. (Thanks Mario and Luigi)! We otherwise are high functioning humans (both valedictorians and hold Master's degrees), but how much did video games actually have to do with that?

Spending a couple of hours on video games a day at age 10 was one thing, but what about children in those sensitive developmental years, particularly ages 0-8? Nowadays, 5-year-olds who play Minecraft are not hard to find. I haven't watched PBS Kids with my son for a while, a time-tested, excellent screen based learning opportunity in its own right,  but at the time ABCMouse was running infomercial after infomercial about their early learning software, featuring 2-year-olds who had learned to read. What will this mean for our future?

Because technology has developed so quickly, it's not surprising it has made its way into early learning classrooms as well. For instance, when I taught Kindergarten, I would use and recommend that parents use the BOB book app. I'll admit it, I loved everything about BOB books- the app as well. Besides that, however, I didn't have a computer in the classroom or a computer lab at my school for general student use. Time spent working in schools as a music teacher/early childhood assistant meant seeing the occasional computer learning station, and computer lab, but not much more than that. Most of my work was for private preschool and K-8 schools, however.

Sending my son to public school Kindergarten - 2nd grade meant getting codes for RAZ Kids and Dreambox. Students used the apps twice weekly in the computer lab. At age 10, my son is both reading and doing math above his grade level- doing great academically. However, so was I at his age, and I didn't have any of that. Somewhat based on data gleaned from these two apps, along with some assessments taken on the computer, teachers were able to determine his reading and math level, and give him supplemental help if needed. I can tell you for sure from some of the research I have done for my Technology for Leaders of Learning class that schools nowadays can store and track student data more than ever- using learning management systems to mark the upward trends created by being more responsive to student needs.

Let try to summarize the "ins" of screen time for young children then, shall we? First, they are a bit of an enigma. It's not easy to give a personal opinion because not only did most parents not have the same type of screen based learning opportunities that their young children do, they haven't been around long enough to really show their long term effects. Learning apps seem to help teachers know how to help students better, which in turn drives student achievement, definitely an "in." Hand-eye coordination, problem solving, creativity- these are skills children can develop on a wide variety of early learning apps. Let's not forget kid friendly TV for early learning, such as PBS Kids. And yes, a 2-year-old can even learn to read and practice basic math skills with software like ABCMouse. That's pretty good, isn't it? Or is it? Tomorrow, I'll write a bit about the "outs" of screen time for young children, in search of a happy medium of course. Stay tuned!

Check out these blogs for more info on screen time for young children:
DigiParenthood
Fred Rogers Center Blog
Jump in for Healthy Kids

Monday, February 18, 2019

Screen Time for Young Children- the Ins and Outs

On this blog, I have written from the perspective of a parent, teacher, and children’s artist to share my experience in providing early learning experiences for children. This week, I’d like to take the opportunity to speak as a leader of learning. As you may know, I am currently working towards a Master’s in Educational Leadership, and I’m taking a class called Technology for leaders of Learning. In this class I have learned about many ways to provide and manage personalized e-learning for students in a classroom setting. 

As a parent, you may have encountered these e-learning resources when your students come home with access codes to RAZ Kids or Dreambox. However, results of multiple studies of the effect of screen time on developing brains have led to pediatrician recommended amounts of screen time for young children. Studies that show harmful effects of screen time on the brain abound. On the other hand, studies also show that learning apps can improve overall student performance.

I have emphasized play based early learning on this blog, in addition to music and movement. I’ve found that not many are highlighting these alternatives to using learning apps or other learning opportunities involving screens. In fact, online, you tend to find links to online learning resources- I am guilty of this myself in promoting my YouTube channel for early learning. Those who opt in for a TV free home, with little to no device use, don’t seem to be as forefront in advocating for their stance on screen time as do advocates of the learning apps themselves. 

As a leader of learning, I am met with this dilemma. How much should I advocate use of learning apps in and out of school? I tend to want to follow pediatrician recommended guidelines, but I also know that learning apps can have a positive effect on overall learning, allowing teachers to keep track of each student’s progress, and providing resources otherwise unavailable or not as easily attained in the classroom. Stay tuned this week and next as I write about the ins and outs of using screen related apps for young children!